The Anaheim Ducks’ offseason took a dramatic turn when they matched the Philadelphia Flyers’ record-setting five-year, $90 million offer sheet for star center Leo Carlsson. While the move ensured the franchise kept one of its cornerstone players, it also sparked immediate speculation about what it could mean for fellow restricted free agent Cutter Gauthier.
After leading Anaheim with 41 goals last season, Gauthier suddenly became the center of contract rumors, with many wondering whether he would now demand a deal similar to Carlsson’s.
Insider Shuts Down Gauthier Contract Rumors
The speculation gained momentum after former NHL defenseman Keith Yandle claimed on Spittin’ Chiclets that he had heard Gauthier wasn’t willing to accept anything less than Carlsson’s $18 million average annual value.
However, NHL insider Jimmy Murphy quickly dismissed the rumor with a blunt four-word response: “Confirmed, this is not true!”
Murphy’s response poured cold water on the growing speculation, suggesting the reported contract demand isn’t based in reality.
The Reality Behind the Gauthier Situation With the Ducks
While the rumor generated plenty of discussion, it doesn’t align with the NHL’s contract rules.
Unlike Carlsson, Gauthier is not eligible to receive an offer sheet because he has not yet qualified for Group 2 restricted free agent status. He also does not have arbitration rights, making the rumored $18 million-per-year scenario impossible under the current collective bargaining agreement.
That said, Anaheim still faces an important negotiation.
Following his 41-goal breakout season, Gauthier is expected to receive a significant raise.
Before Carlsson’s record-setting contract, projections had Gauthier landing a long-term deal worth roughly $9.6 million annually. With the market now shifting upward, he could reasonably seek a contract in the $11-12 million range or opt for a shorter-term agreement that allows him to capitalize on another increase in the salary cap later.
Even if Gauthier signs for around $11-12 million annually, Anaheim will need to create cap space before the regular season.
That has already fueled speculation that veterans such as Alex Killorn and Frank Vatrano could become trade candidates as general manager Pat Verbeek looks to balance the books.
Negotiations may not be straightforward either. Verbeek is notoriously rigid in contract negotiations (as seen previously with Trevor Zegras and Jamie Drysdale). However, Gauthier famously forced his way out of Philadelphia by refusing to sign his ELC, proving he is entirely comfortable digging his heels in when he feels slighted by front-office management.
The Ducks can’t afford a prolonged holdout from their top goalscorer, meaning Verbeek will likely have to swallow his pride, move a veteran asset for pennies on the dollar, and pay Gauthier his well-earned premium.
