The NFL supplemental draft has not produced a selection since 2019, when the Cardinals spent a fifth-round bid on safety Jalen Thompson. Brendan Sorsby is about to make it matter again.
The Texas Tech transfer was ruled permanently ineligible by the NCAA after admitting to roughly $90,000 in sports bets, including wagers on his own Indiana team as a freshman. He won a temporary injunction to play in 2026, then walked away from the legal fight entirely.
By withdrawing his lawsuit and entering the supplemental draft ahead of a June 22 deadline, Sorsby forfeited his remaining eligibility and handed all 32 front offices a decision: spend future capital on a tools-rich passer once viewed as a potential first-round pick, or pass.
He will not lack for suitors, because the league’s quarterback landscape has rarely been this unsettled. But one team stands out as both the likeliest bidder and the most sensible fit, and it is the team that always seems to be in this conversation, the Cleveland Browns.
Why Brendan Sorsby Is the Supplemental Draft’s Most Intriguing QB in Years
Sorsby’s appeal is the rare mix of pedigree and price. He threw for 7,208 yards and accounted for 82 total touchdowns across stops at Indiana and Cincinnati, and PFN draft analyst Ian Cummings graded him as a mid-to-late Day 2 prospect had he declared for the 2026 class.
“If the Steelers wanted to take a QB who I believe has a higher floor and a potentially higher ceiling as an athlete and a thrower, I think Brendan Sorsby would be a very prudent investment,” Cummings said on PFN’s The Hot List.
The carousel gives several teams a reason to look. Tampa Bay is locked in a contract standoff with Baker Mayfield, who is seeking north of $50 million per year on an extension. Minnesota hedged its J.J. McCarthy bet by signing Kyler Murray to a one-year, veteran-minimum deal.
Pittsburgh is riding Aaron Rodgers’ final season at 42, with an unproven room of Mason Rudolph, Will Howard and rookie Drew Allar behind him under new coach Mike McCarthy. The Jets reacquired Geno Smith and hold three first-round picks in 2027, so they could add a developmental arm without touching that haul.
BE THE GM OF YOUR FAVORITE TEAM: PFN’s FREE NFL Mock Draft Simulator
Cummings sees a player built to weather early adversity, noting Sorsby was one of just 33 qualifying quarterbacks in 2025 to avoid negative EPA on pressured dropbacks, per PFSN’s metrics. “With his athleticism, his arm talent, he might have the tools to withstand adversity a little better than some other QBs early on,” he said.
Why the Cleveland Browns Make the Most Sense for Brendan Sorsby
No team needs the swing more than Cleveland. Shedeur Sanders and Dillon Gabriel combined for one of the league’s least productive quarterback rooms as 2025 rookies, and a 30-year-old Deshaun Watson, coming off another lost season, is not the answer.
“Let’s be honest, the Browns still need a QB,” Cummings said. “The bar is about as low as it can be in Cleveland.”
That low bar is the opportunity. The Browns are stacked with 2027 draft capital and a surplus of mid-round picks, so they could absorb Sorsby in the fourth round of the supplemental process without mortgaging anything. They also spent the 2026 offseason rebuilding the supporting cast, drafting receivers KC Concepcion and Denzel Boston and reinforcing the offensive line in front of head coach Todd Monken’s scheme.
“I think the Todd Monken offense with the motions and screen usage and RPO plays to his strengths a little bit,” Cummings said.
REDRAFT THE ENTIRE NFL: PFN’s FREE NFL Ultimate Redraft Simulator
Sorsby will take his lumps if he plays early. In a city that has chased a franchise quarterback since the team’s 1999 return, though, a tools-rich developmental arm with a real supporting cast is exactly the bet Cleveland should want to make. For once, the low bar might be the selling point.
