Kirk Herbstreit Issues Fernando Mendoza Verdict As Caleb Williams, Cam Ward Comparison Drawn

ESPN analyst Kirk Herbstreit compared former Indiana quarterback Fernando Mendoza to some of the previous NFL No. 1 draft picks.

Former Indiana Hoosiers quarterback Fernando Mendoza is widely considered the undisputed No. 1 pick in the 2026 NFL Draft. After a historic season during which he led the Hoosiers to the Big Ten and national championships, Mendoza distinguished himself as the best player in college football, culminating in a Heisman Trophy win.

Mendoza has been repeatedly linked with a move to the Las Vegas Raiders, who own the No. 1 pick on draft night after finishing last season with a 3-14 record.

PFSN 2026-2027 CFB Playoff Predictor
Play out the entire college football season with PFSN's CFB Playoff Predictor to see what it means for conference standings and the CFB playoffs!

Kirk Herbstreit Compares Fernando Mendoza to Previous No. 1 Picks

During Thursday’s segment of the “This is Football” show, ESPN analyst Kirk Herbstreit weighed in on Mendoza’s strengths in the NFL, while comparing him with the previous year’s No. 1 picks.

“I just don’t think he’s a Justin Herbert coming out of Oregon, that he’s so skilled, we’re gonna grow around him, and eventually he’s gonna keep us afloat, and eventually we’re gonna become elite once we get the right pieces around him,” Herbstreit said. “He’s a mind guy. He’s gonna hurt you with his mind. His preparation. His processing.”

ALSO READ: Kirk Herbstreit Reveals Why Chiefs Superstar Patrick Mahomes’ NFL Dominance Caught Him Completely Off Guard

He continued, “He’s elite at that level, and that’s 90% of the game. If you have the pieces around him, he’s a guy that you’re gonna fall in love with. He’s not your typical kid coming out of college. He’s mobile enough, but he’s not Caleb Williams, he’s not Cam Ward with the ability to make people miss.”

The Raiders’ offense struggled last season under former coach Pete Carroll, with veteran quarterback Geno Smith finishing with 19 touchdowns, 17 interceptions, and 55 sacks, behind a leaky offensive line.

Urban Meyer Raises Mendoza to the Raiders Warning

During an appearance on “The Herd” on Wednesday, former Ohio State coach Urban Meyer lavished praise on Mendoza’s NFL-readiness, while warning the former quarterback about the Raiders’ organizational issues.

“I spent so much time with Mendoza. He’s more than ready. I compare him to Drake Maye. I just think that the guy is a coach on the field,” Meyer said. “The best version of Mendoza we’ve not seen yet. I just love this kid.”

“Like all first picks in the draft, you’re gonna go with the Raiders. Mark Ingram said that’s the worst pro football team he’s ever seen. My worry is, he gets stuck on a really bad team, and then he’s labeled a bust, which I can’t stand. QBs on bad teams are not busts.”

Mendoza had a historic season for the Hoosiers, earning a PFSN College QB Impact score of 93.3 after tallying 3,535 passing yards, resulting in 41 touchdowns and six interceptions, while adding 276 rushing yards and seven touchdowns.

More CFB Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

More CFB Articles

‘Made the Ultimate Sacrifice’ — Tributes Pour In As Kirk Herbstreit, CFB World Honor Fallen Heroes on Memorial Day

Several tributes poured in for the fallen troops from the college football world on Monday during the 2026 Memorial Day.

‘This Is the Caveat’ — Former NFL MVP Declares Kalen DeBoer Is the Wrong Fit for $87.5M Alabama Job

Cam Newton evaluates Kalen DeBoer's position at Alabama, claiming crushing expectations of succeeding Nick Saban won't give him any grace.

‘That’s Just Impossible Now’ — CFB Analyst Warns Kirby Smart Faces a Problem Georgia Can’t Fix

SEC Network analyst Chris Doering explains why the transfer portal and NIL have eroded Georgia's trademark elite roster depth under Kirby Smart.