The New England Patriots’ backfield entered a new phase following Antonio Gibson’s season-ending ACL injury. Rhamondre Stevenson and TreVeyon Henderson now split duties in what has become one of fantasy’s most frustrating committee situations. Can fantasy football managers trust either Patriots runner against Tennessee’s vulnerable defense?
Rhamondre Stevenson Fantasy Outlook
Stevenson received the primary beneficiary treatment in the first game without Antonio Gibson, playing a season-high 70% of snaps against New Orleans. However, he failed to capitalize on this expanded opportunity, managing just 18 scoreless yards on 13 carries resulting in an abysmal 1.8 fantasy points. His efficiency concerns have become undeniable despite increased volume.
The coaching staff continues showing faith in Stevenson despite his struggles throughout the season. His route-running involvement remains superior to Henderson’s, maintaining a 41.8% route share that keeps him involved in passing situations. This versatility provides weekly floor protection even when his rushing production disappoints.
MORE: Free Fantasy Football Start/Sit Optimizer
Stevenson’s goal-line usage provides his most reliable path to weekly fantasy relevance. He handled both of the team’s red zone carries against the Saints, demonstrating continued trust in short-yardage situations where touchdowns can salvage otherwise poor statistical performances.
His 12th-ranked missed tackles forced per attempt among qualifying backs suggests his underlying skills remain intact despite recent struggles. However, his 2.1 yards per carry average over the past three games creates legitimate concerns about his effectiveness within New England’s struggling offensive system.
TreVeyon Henderson Fantasy Outlook
Henderson’s role remained unchanged despite Gibson’s departure, continuing to operate as a change-of-pace option rather than assuming expanded responsibilities. His 29% snap share represented his lowest playing time of the season, highlighting the coaching staff’s reluctance to increase his involvement significantly.
His 3.6 yards per carry average reflects efficiency struggles that mirror Stevenson’s disappointing production. Henderson has generated zero explosive runs through six games while ranking 46th in missed tackle rate and 47th in yards after contact per attempt among qualified backs. These metrics suggest fundamental issues with his ability to create additional value beyond blocking schemes.
READ MORE: Soppe’s Week 7 Fantasy Football Start ‘Em Sit ‘Em: Analysis for Every Player in Every Game
Henderson’s 10.4% target share indicates minimal involvement in the passing game, limiting his weekly floor protection compared to Stevenson’s more prominent receiving role. The coaching staff’s reluctance to utilize him on passing downs suggests limited confidence in his route-running abilities or pass protection skills.
His inability to make himself indispensable during limited opportunities has prevented role expansion. Henderson needs explosive plays to force increased touches, but his lack of big-play creation has allowed Stevenson to maintain primary status despite equally concerning efficiency metrics.
Should You Start Stevenson or Henderson This Week?
Tennessee presents excellent conditions for both Patriots backs, allowing the fourth-most schedule-adjusted fantasy points to running backs. The Titans have surrendered nine rushing touchdowns in six weeks while ranking 26th in run defense, creating favorable matchup dynamics for New England’s ground game.
However, favorable matchups haven’t translated to reliable production for either player this season. Both backs have consistently disappointed despite facing defenses that should theoretically create scoring opportunities. This pattern suggests systemic issues with New England’s offensive approach rather than matchup-specific problems.
Fantasy managers should expect the split to remain roughly 70-30 in Stevenson’s favor based on recent usage patterns. His superior snap share and goal-line role make him the preferred option among the two, though neither represents a confident weekly starter given their combined struggles.
Stevenson functions as a desperation flex play for fantasy managers facing bye weeks and injuries. His volume advantage and touchdown equity provide modest weekly upside that Henderson currently lacks through his limited role and poor efficiency metrics.
Neither Patriots back can be trusted in fantasy lineups until demonstrating significant improvement. The combination of poor efficiency, struggling offensive line play, and unpredictable game scripts creates too many obstacles for reliable weekly production.
