One impressive preseason performance can change everything in the NFL. For Cleveland Browns rookie quarterback Shedeur Sanders, Friday night’s debut against the Carolina Panthers might have been exactly that kind of breakthrough moment. After delivering a composed showing in his first real opportunity, Sanders has suddenly thrust himself into a quarterback competition that was already fascinating enough without his emergence.
What Did Shedeur Sanders Show Against the Panthers?
Before the Browns’ preseason matchup against the Carolina Panthers, NFL analyst Dan Orlovsky weighed in on Sanders, posting on X: “If Shedeur plays well tonight, He 100% should get reps next week with the 2’s and 1’s in Browns practices.”
If Shedeur plays well tonight
He 100% should get reps next week with the 2’s and 1’s in @Browns practices
— Dan Orlovsky (@danorlovsky7) August 8, 2025
Sanders delivered on Orlovsky’s challenge, completing 14 of 23 passes for 138 yards and two touchdowns while adding 19 rushing yards. The fifth-round rookie looked comfortable in the pocket and showed the poise that made him a standout at Colorado. His dual-threat ability was on full display, creating plays with both his arm and legs when the pocket broke down.
After the game, Sanders explained that he felt calm and just needed time to settle into the flow. That composure was evident throughout his performance, as he avoided the rookie mistakes that often plague young quarterbacks making their debuts.
How Is Kevin Stefanski Handling the Quarterback Competition?
Despite Sanders’ impressive showing, head coach Kevin Stefanski remained characteristically measured in his post-game comments. The coach avoided confirming whether Sanders would see more work with the first or second teams moving forward.
“I’m pleased with the way Shedeur played, I’m pleased with the way the offense operated,” Stefanski told reporters. “All things moving forward as we continue to practice will be focused on all of our guys’ development and getting these guys ready to ready to play for the season.”
Stefanski’s diplomatic approach makes sense given the complexity of Cleveland’s quarterback room. The coach highlighted one particular throw to receiver Luke Floriea, calling it an impressive effort from both players. However, he emphasized that upcoming practices would focus on developing every player and preparing them for the regular season rather than making immediate depth chart adjustments.
The Browns’ quarterback competition has multiple layers due to Sanders’ unexpected emergence. Selected in the fifth round despite his talent, the rookie now faces competition from veterans Joe Flacco and Kenny Pickett, as well as third-round rookie Dillon Gabriel. Typically, a fifth-round pick doesn’t start high on the depth chart, but circumstances have created an opening.
What Opportunities Opened the Door for Sanders?
Sanders found himself in this position partly due to injuries affecting his competition. Pickett and Gabriel have dealt with health issues, while Flacco’s age will likely prevent him from seeing any significant preseason action. These factors combined to give Sanders meaningful snaps in Friday’s game, representing his first true shot to make a statement.
The rookie capitalized on that opportunity, showing he belongs on the field with more experienced players. His performance has fans wondering if he can continue climbing the depth chart ahead of the regular season.
Looking ahead, Stefanski confirmed that Sanders will receive plenty of playing time in the Browns’ upcoming preseason matchup with the Philadelphia Eagles. Whether that includes time with the starters or second unit will depend on the health of Pickett and Gabriel, plus Flacco’s level of involvement.
ESPN reported that the Browns will likely retain four quarterbacks during training camp, indicating Sanders isn’t at risk of being cut at this stage. With a few more performances like Friday’s effort against Carolina, he could push for a more significant role sooner than anyone expected when camp began.
