Ever since he lost the Undisputed WWE Championship to John Cena at WrestleMania 41, Cody Rhodes has been absent from the ring. His 378-day title reign came to a dramatic end, and fans have been buzzing ever since, wondering when “The American Nightmare” will return.
It seems WWE may have offered a major clue on his future. Rhodes is featured on the official page (click here to see) for the May 23 episode of Friday Night SmackDown, along with Randy Orton, LA Knight, Solo Sikoa, and Jacob Fatu.
Cody Rhodes Featured On WWE’s Official Poster for Friday Night SmackDown
His inclusion on the event page has sparked speculation that May 23 could mark Rhodes’ long-awaited comeback. That episode of SmackDown is just one night before Saturday Night’s Main Event, giving the timing extra weight. A surprise return in that spot could send shockwaves through the wrestling world and potentially set the stage for a marquee storyline heading into summer.
There are several intriguing directions WWE could go with Rhodes. A rematch with Cena to reclaim the Undisputed Championship would certainly grab headlines. On the other hand, a feud with Jacob Fatu for the United States Title could offer something fresh and give Rhodes an immediate purpose upon his return. WWE could also surprise fans by inserting him into the ongoing Money in the Bank qualifiers, allowing him to earn a briefcase that guarantees another title shot.
JOHN CENA TURNS HEEL ON CODY RHODES AND SIDES WITH THE ROCK pic.twitter.com/uAFR5TeIKJ
— Dante Turo (@DanteOnDeck) March 2, 2025
This strategic placement on WWE’s official poster doesn’t seem accidental. WWE typically doesn’t promote sidelined talent unless there’s a purpose. The decision to feature Rhodes on this particular SmackDown feels deliberate and carefully calculated, especially given the momentum needed after a post-WrestleMania lull.
If Rhodes does return, it raises a few important questions.
Will he reignite a feud with Cena, go after a different title, or possibly align or feud with one of the emerging Bloodline members like Sikoa or Fatu? WWE has been weaving layered narratives around the Bloodline and Rhodes since 2023, and his comeback could provide a major jolt to existing storylines.
Whether he reignites a rivalry, begins a new chase for gold, or takes an unexpected path, Rhodes’ return could shift the momentum on SmackDown in a big way. All signs now point to May 23, as WWE’s landscape may be on the verge of a major shakeup.