News of Brock Purdy’s blockbuster five-year, $265 million contract extension with the San Francisco 49ers sent shockwaves through the NFL and sparked an immediate, passionate reaction from fans across social media.
The deal, which includes $181 million in total guarantees and runs through 2030, cements Purdy’s status as one of the league’s highest-paid quarterbacks. But the eye-popping numbers have left the 49ers’ fan base deeply divided.
Brock Purdy Overpaid? Or Worth the Investment? Fans Share Their Thoughts.
“Lmaoooooo holy overpay!” one fan wrote on X, echoing a sentiment shared by many who believe the 49ers paid too steep a price for their young signal-caller. Others, however, argued that Purdy’s performance since taking over as starter – including leading the team to two NFC Championship Games and a Super Bowl appearance – more than justifies the investment.
“He has a better resume than most of the other QBs that recently got paid, so there’s absolutely no reason he should take less than them,” one supporter commented
Some fans expressed relief that the contract saga had ended, with one writing, “If Brock gets 50 mil a year or less I’ll consider that a huge W for the Niners,” while others warned that the deal could hamper the team’s ability to build a competitive roster around Purdy in the future
Skeptics pointed to Purdy’s dip in production last season and questioned whether he warrants a top-of-the-market contract. “That is too much, but more than fair for a QB coming off of a 6-11 year,” another fan posted. Others noted his status as the last pick in the 2022 draft, suggesting that some of his limitations remain apparent.
Still, a vocal contingent believes the 49ers made the right move. “Not enough. As a 9er fan he deserves it all. Give him a cut of the concessions too,” one fan joked.
With Purdy now locked in as the franchise quarterback, the debate among 49ers fans is likely to continue as the team sets its sights on another Super Bowl run. For now, the only consensus is that the 49ers’ latest move has everyone talking.
Critics note that Purdy’s production dipped in 2024 as the team struggled with injuries and missed the playoffs, with his EPA per play and quarterback rating falling out of the league’s elite. Some observers question whether his success is more a product of the 49ers’ strong supporting cast and coaching than individual brilliance, and whether he should command a salary on par with the league’s top quarterbacks.
Ultimately, the size of Purdy’s contract reflects both the going rate for starting quarterbacks in today’s NFL and the 49ers’ belief that he is their long-term answer under center.. While there is room for debate, Purdy’s early-career achievements and the market for quarterbacks make a strong case that he has, at minimum, earned the opportunity to justify the investment.
With his extension in place, he will be expected to prove he can sustain that level of play as the face of the franchise.