The Dallas Cowboys trade for quarterback Joe Milton III from the New England Patriots has sparked debate across the NFL.
Dallas sent a fifth-round pick (No. 171) to acquire Milton and a seventh-rounder (No. 217) — a move that drew sharp criticism from Colin Cowherd during an episode of “The Herd.”
Cowherd didn’t hold back, calling the deal another example of Jerry Jones mismanaging draft assets in pursuit of questionable talent. Milton was drafted in the sixth round of the 2024 NFL Draft, No. 193 overall.
Colin Cowherd’s Strong Words
Cowherd, known for his blunt takes, questioned the logic behind Jones’ decision to spend draft capital on Milton, a player widely viewed as — at best — a developmental project.
“Jerry Jones was threatened by Bill Parcells and Jimmy Johnson, and they’ve only had really one star first-round quarterback since Jerry has been there, and that’s Troy Aikman,” Cowherd said. “And then Jerry gave up a fifth-rounder for Joe Milton, who’s a clear backup.”
Many analysts argue that fifth-round picks are critical for finding hidden-gem contributors. The move adds to years of scrutiny around Jones’ draft approach, with Cowherd emphasizing how mid-round picks can build depth — or even land stars like San Francisco 49ers tight end George Kittle. The San Francisco 49ers selected Kittle in the fifth round of the 2017 NFL Draft, at No. 146 overall.
“Successful teams,” Cowherd added, “find hidden gems in rounds like the fifth, turning them into reliable contributors.” His comments echo a broader concern among fans and analysts about whether Jones’ decisions are keeping the Cowboys competitive — or locking them in mediocrity.
Joe Milton III’s Profile and Stats
Milton, the former Tennessee quarterback, is an intriguing prospect thanks to his physical tools. At 6’5″ and 246 pounds, he has the size and arm strength NFL teams look for. Milton made headlines at the 2024 NFL Combine with a 62-yard deep throw during drills, showcasing rare arm talent.
But while Milton’s raw tools stand out, his college production was uneven. In his final season at Tennessee, he threw for 2,813 yards, 20 touchdowns and 5 interceptions, completing just 64.7% of his passes. He also ran for 299 yards and seven scores, adding mobility to his résumé.
Still, questions about Milton’s consistency, decision-making and NFL readiness remain — fueling the criticism surrounding the Cowboys’ trade.
The spotlight stays on Jones and the Cowboys as fans and analysts continue to weigh in on the Milton move. Whether he develops into a reliable backup — or somehow becomes a surprise starter — will shape how this controversial trade is remembered in Dallas franchise history.