Jayson Tatum has long been a polarizing figure in the NBA despite his undeniable success. The Boston Celtics star, who is also a six-time All-Star and three-time All-NBA first-team selection, led his team to the 2024 NBA championship, yet criticism of his game persists.
Fans and media often overlook him in discussions about the league’s top players, sparking debates about his legacy. Whether it’s his playing style or perceived lack of “superstar aura,” Tatum remains a lightning rod for scrutiny.
During his appearance on The Pat McAfee Show, Indiana Pacers point guard Tyrese Haliburton defended Tatum about his play. Haliburton’s remarks come as Tatum has received intensive criticism after Celtics fans spent their summer watching televised arguments about the team’s championship victory.
His assessment brings a new viewpoint from a fellow NBA player to show Tatum’s standing in the league and spark more conversations regarding his public perception.
Haliburton Calls Out Jayson Tatum’s Critics
Haliburton didn’t hold back, labeling the hate Tatum receives as “unwarranted.” He pointed to Tatum as the cornerstone of the NBA’s top team, emphasizing his elite status. “I think it’s unwarranted, he’s an elite player in our league and the best player on the best team,” Haliburton said on the show.
According to the Pacers guard, the criticism against Tatum partly stems from his Duke education and Boston Celtics association. Haliburton identified Duke University and the Celtics basketball team as possible reasons people criticize Tatum.
According to him, these elements in society create unfair impressions about Tatum, which erase his dominant playing skills and role in winning the championship with his team.
Tatum’s Complex Legacy In Spotlight
Current discussions about Tatum’s legacy continue even during his winning period. The data shows Tatum placed third in NBA jersey sales in 2025, yet several analysts discuss whether he will attain the same “legendary status” as Nikola Jokic and Giannis Antetokounmpo and thus ignite ongoing discussions about his accomplishments.
Tatum has voiced frustration over the lack of respect he feels. In a past interview, he tied being a winner to being an all-time great, a perspective critics argue doesn’t match traditional measures of NBA greatness, keeping him in the spotlight.