Paul Skenes has emerged as one of Major League Baseball’s most dynamic talents. The Pittsburgh Pirates’ ace has made a name for himself as one of the most valued arms in the game thanks to his powerful fastball, superb control, and maturity beyond his years. However, because of the Pirates’ inability to score runs when he starts and concerns about the franchise’s long-term future, some leaguers have started to envision a crazy scenario: what if a team like the Boston Red Sox made a genuine effort to trade for Skenes?
Insider Believes Boston Offers Potential Package
MLB Network insider Greg Amsinger recently floated a bold hypothetical: “If Paul Skenes was traded to the Boston Red Sox for Marcelo Mayer, Roman Anthony, and Kristian Campbell… would you do that if you’re the Pirates?”
Mayer and Anthony are Boston’s top two prospects, both projected to be future stars. Campbell is already turning heads at the big-league level and is in contention for American League Rookie of the Year. That’s a serious package, and on paper, it might be one of the few that could even tempt a team to consider moving a player of Skenes’ caliber.
Still, others see the idea as completely off-limits. Former MLB pitcher Dan Plesac pushed back strongly against the notion of dealing Skenes.
“I’m not into trading him because he’s the identity of the Pirates,” Plesac said.
That’s a sentiment many in Pittsburgh would echo. Skenes isn’t just the ace of the rotation; he’s become the face of a franchise still looking to recapture its winning identity. Trading him would signal a massive step backward in the eyes of fans who finally have someone to rally around.
What do YOU think? #MLBTonight https://t.co/mWh0zrNAtM pic.twitter.com/A34pBC6K0h
— MLB Network (@MLBNetwork) June 5, 2025
Paul Skenes is Untouchable; Or Is He Really?
Even if many people believe Skenes cannot be touched, it’s reasonable to assume that Boston has the resources and the drive to at least give him a call. The Red Sox have the young MLB talent and depth of their farm system to put together an alluring package. More significantly, they are a team that hopes to make the playoffs and might provide Skenes with run support, which he hasn’t had much of in Pittsburgh.
Notably, Skenes has done everything in his power to support the Pirates’ victory. However, a number of his outstanding performances have ended in frustrating defeats due to the team’s offensive inefficiencies. In addition to providing the Red Sox with a pitcher of the next generation, a transfer to Boston might alter the direction of their rotation for years to come.
The rumor shows how sought-after Skenes has become, even though the Pirates are unlikely to trade with their franchise mainstay anytime soon. Additionally, the discussion may not be as one-sided as many believe if a team like Boston makes the proper offer.