The Dallas Cowboys are entering the 2025 NFL season with renewed hope and notable roster changes. But despite the optimism surrounding the franchise, not all voices in the media are convinced. One NFL analyst delivered a sobering assessment that casts doubt on Dallas’ chances in a fiercely competitive NFC East.
NFL Analyst: Cowboys Don’t Match Eagles in Roster, Coaching or Front Office
On ESPN’s “Get Up,” NFL analyst Kevin Clark offered a blunt evaluation of where the Cowboys stand within their division.
“The Dallas Cowboys are the third-best team in the NFC East,” Clark said, before adding, “I don’t think there’s much of a pathway unless something catastrophic happens with the first two teams in that division.” His remarks emphasized not only skepticism but also a perceived structural gap between Dallas and its divisional rivals.
Clark’s main point centers on what he sees as a significant disparity in talent between the Cowboys and the Eagles. He pointed out that Philadelphia’s roster strength, from top to bottom, puts them in a different league entirely.
“We saw that the last few years. I just think that when you go 1-53, the Eagles have the best roster in football,” he continued. According to Clark, Dallas doesn’t hold an advantage in any key area — coaching, front office, or even defense.
Interestingly, this isn’t the first time Clark has sounded the alarm on the Cowboys’ trajectory. While discussing Dallas’ acquisition of wide receiver George Pickens in May, he acknowledged the positive impact but remained unconvinced it would shift the division hierarchy. Clark said the move improved the Cowboys, but maintained it didn’t elevate them above the Philadelphia Eagles or Washington Commanders.
This sentiment stood in contrast with the optimism of fellow analyst Mina Kimes, who highlighted how Pickens and CeeDee Lamb could elevate the offense. Kimes argued that Pickens’ presence might open up the run game, a glaring weakness in 2024. Cowboys fans have reason to be encouraged, especially considering the injuries that plagued last season. A healthier offense could yield very different results.
Still, Clark’s evaluation doesn’t hinge on isolated improvements. His position remains firm — no single addition can overcome what he sees as a systemic disadvantage.
“I don’t see the edges where Dallas is going to be able to close that gap,” he said. “I don’t see a coaching edge. I don’t see a GM edge. I don’t see a defensive edge.”
In Clark’s view, even if offensive coordinator Brian Schottenheimer surprises, “not to anything better than third place in that division.” For Cowboys supporters, it’s a brutal reality check that suggests optimism may once again collide with the weight of the NFC East’s top-heavy structure.